Medical Spa MD is a community of 28,000+ plastic surgeons, dermatologists, & aesthetic physicians practicing cosmetic medicine worldwide. FREE Medical Spa Deals for Clinicians

About   |   Advertise   |   Press   |   Contact

Sponsors & Friends

cosmetic fillers ad

Medical Spa RX Group Buy Program.

medical spa design and advertising

Graphic Design for Medical Spas

Waiting Room Video DVD Marketing

The very best bang for your buck cosmetic marketing!
Watch demo Frontdesk waiting room videos and DVDs.

Medical Spa Training Manuals

Medical spa & laser clinic staff training manuals.

2nd MD
2nd MD - Boarded US physicians work from anywhere.
Medical Justice
Relentlessly protecting physicians from frivolous lawsuits.

More control of your income, career, and lifestyle as a physician.
Read our terms
Newest Comments

Medical Spa MD is a world-wide physician community for clinicians in skin clinics, laser centers and medspas with thousands of physician members around the world. By using this site you agree to our terms of service and fine print.

« Botox Study May Lead To Longer Treatment Duration. | Main | Now You Can Offer The John Hopkins Skin Care Line In Your Medispa? »
Saturday
Apr082006

Study: Safety & Performance of Reactivated Thermage Thermacool Tips.

Before or after reading this post on a supposed study show that reactivated Thermage tips can be used for 50,000 pulses, read this post by Thermage: Thermage responds to study showing reactivated Thermage tips are safe.

 

Safety and performance of reactivated Thermage Thermacool tips.
Michael Stevens M.D., et all

Abstract

small%203.0cm%20button.jpg This study investigated the safety and performance of reactivated Thermage Thermacool tips. The Thermacool machine, made by Thermage Inc. in Hayward California, uses radio frequency (RF) energy to treat a variety of dermatological cosmetic conditions. The machine’s hand piece is coupled to a plastic tip which incorporates a microchip. This microchip contains data which limits the number of shots which the tip can be used for. By attaching an aftermarket replacement microchip (with the exact same data) to the plastic tip, the tip can be reused for many more shots. This study investigated in detail the safety and performance of such reactivated tips. The study found that the tips could be safely reactivated and used for more than 50,000 shots (more than 55 reactivations) with the same safety, performance and clinical results as obtained from a new tip.

Background and Objectives

The Thermacool machine, made by Thermage Inc. in Hayward California, uses radio frequency (RF) energy to treat a variety of dermatological cosmetic conditions. The machine consists of a main unit which incorporates a computer, power supply, and other components. The main unit is attached to a hand piece that has the components necessary to generate the RF energy and deliver cryogen coolant to a plastic tip. A plastic tip attaches to the hand piece and directs the RF energy and cryogen coolant to the patient’s skin. The plastic tip incorporates an EPROM microchip which contains data to tell the Thermacool machine as to how many shot the tip can be used for. Once the allowed number of shots has been used with the specified tip, the machine no longer allows the use of that particular plastic tip. The user of the device is then forced to throw away the used tip and purchase a new tip from Thermage at a very expensive price.

0000.gifRead Thermage's reaction to this supposed study here: Thermage responds to physicians using reactivated tips.

Thermage claims that they have limited the use of the tips because of safety reasons. They claim that the tips are safe to be used only for the number of shots which they have been programmed for. However, Thermage currently produces identical tips which are programmed to be used for 150 shots, 200 shots, 300 shots, 450 shots, 600 shots, and 900 shots. Examination of the different plastic tips shows that they are all identical in their construction and quality. The only difference between them is the programming of the EPROM microchip to limit the number of shots used by each tip. This clearly shows that Thermage is aware that a tip which they have programmed for 150 shots can be safely used for as many as 900 shots, which is 6 times the number of 150 shots! This has lead many doctors who use the Thermacool machine to conclude that Thermage is limiting the number of shots on the tips for monetary gain and not for safety reasons.

Thermage has claimed that their Thermacool tips are made as a one-time use device for the following reasons: they claim that the membrane on the plastic tips deteriorates and is not safe for use after the allowed number of shots. Thermage also claims that the tips are limited to one-time use because of sterility reasons. All of these claims were fully investigated in this study and found to be incorrect.

Methods

20 new Thermacool plastic tips was taken apart and examined in detail. Tips of the size 1.0cm and 1.5cm were examined. Tips from all manufactured shot counts were examined. Components of the plastic tips were sent to experts in the fields of RF, computer circuitry, and various other manufacturing fields. All Thermacool plastic tips of the various shot counts (150 shots, 200 shots, 300 shots, 450 shots, 600 shots, 900 shots) were found to be identical in their composition, materials, and quality. The only difference between the tips was the programming of the EPROM microchip inside the tips.

Thermacool plastic tips were found to be a simple device made of ABS plastic. The plastic tip incorporated a standard thin film of a flexible electronic circuit (made of a thin flexible plastic), which incorporated small temperature sensors and an EPROM microchip. The EPROM microchip was programmed to the number of shots which the tips had been assigned and the size of the tip (1.0cm or 1.5cm tip).

The flexible circuit inside the plastic tip was positioned such that the center of the flexible circuit functioned as the “membrane” of the plastic tip. The “membrane” is the part of the tip which comes in contact with the skin during a treatment. This portion of the flexible circuit contained the temperature sensors to sense the skin’s temperature during the treatment. Analysis of the temperature sensors by experts in the field of electronic circuitry has confirmed that the temperature sensors are standard temperature sensors used in many electronics devices. These sensors have a very long life span of more than 10,000 hours of operation within their range of operating temperatures.

Each temperature sensor was found to have a contact lead at the other end of the flexible circuit such that when the flexible circuit was wrapped inside the plastic tip, the contact leads were positioned where the Thermacool hand piece touches the plastic tip’s connections. These leads then come in contact with the leads of the Thermacool hand piece to allow the machine to receive signals from the temperature sensors.

The EPROM microchip is also incorporated into the flexible circuit, covered within the body of the plastic tip. The EPROM microchip was found to be of a type which allows information to be written to it once only. This does not allow the reprogramming of the microchip once it has already been written to. The microchip communicates to the Thermacool’s main computer via two contact leads which are positioned at the same location as the contact leads of the temperature sensors. These leads then come in contact with the leads of the Thermacool hand piece to allow the machine to read the data from the microchip.

The fact that an EPROM microchip was used, which could only be written to once, it was not possible to reprogram the microchip inside the original tip in order to reactivate the plastic tips once they had been used. Therefore, new blank EPROM microchips were purchased from the same microchip manufacturer. The microchips were then programmed to the EXACT SAME data as a new tip from Thermage. A special flexible circuit was designed to allow the new microchip to be attached from the outside of the used Thermacool tips. Our designed flexible circuit contained 2 contact leads identical to the tip’s contact leads, which were attached to the plastic tip by the use of double tape. The 2 contact leads overlay the plastic tip’s original contact leads of the microchip, thus bypassing the original microchip inside the used tip and allowing the Thermacool machine to read the data from the newly programmed microchip. This simple design alleviated the need to make any alterations to the structural integrity of the plastic tips. No modifications or changes were made to the tips in any way.

The reactivation microchips were then attached to used tips and used on actual patients who consented to the study. Patients were randomly assigned to one of the two groups. One group treated with new tips, and the other group treated with reactivated used tips. Patients were blinded and did not know which group they were assigned to.

In total, 20 used Thermacool tips were used in the experiment, 10 of 1.0cm tips and 10 of 1.5cm tips. Each used Thermacool tip was reactivated by attaching to it a newly programmed microchip. Before each treatment, each tip’s membrane was also carefully cleaned and sterilized with alcohol pads to ensure sterility. The tips were then attached to the Thermacool hand piece and standard treatments were performed on the patients. Each reactivated tip was used on a single patient. Careful documentation was made as to whether patients reported any unusual side effects such as increased pain, erythema, burns, infections or other complaints. At the end of each patient’s treatment series, they were asked to fill out a questionnaire to report any side effects, infections, and if they noticed favorable clinical results from the treatment.

Once the number of shots were used on each tip after a single treatment, the tip was sent for testing and analysis. After each reactivation and use, the tip’s membrane was carefully examined. The membranes were visually examined for any cuts, breaks, tears or compromises in the integrity of the flexible circuit membrane. Small folds or wrinkles in the membrane were not a factor as these were present in many new tips from Thermage. The visual inspection was done by 3 different individuals at different times to ensure a non-biased examination of each tip.

After the visual examination of the membrane, each tip was tested for proper temperature sensing. Each used tip was subjected to various temperatures: 80 degrees Fahrenheit, 100 degrees, and 120 degrees. Individual temperature readings were obtained from all temperature sensors in the plastic tip and compared to readings from new Thermacool tips exposed to the same settings.

In the next stage of testing, the tips were tested for proper cryogen coolant delivery. The same coolant cryogen used by the Thermacool machine, Freon gas (R-134a, also called tetrafluoroethane), was used. At first, a visual inspection of the inner part of the plastic tip was done to make sure that no blockages have been formed on the plastic tip. A controlled cryogen coolant spray was applied to the area of the plastic tip which delivers the cryogen coolant to the tip’s membrane. The membrane’s temperature was then recorded and compared to the readings obtained from new Thermacool tips undergoing the same controlled cryogen coolant spray.

Lastly, a final visual inspection was performed on each tip to ensure that there were no other structural damaged or changes to the integrity of the plastic tip or contact leads which connect to the Thermacool hand piece.

Each used Thermacool tip was reactivated and used for a total of 50,000 shots, which translated to 50-100 reactivations/treatments based on the number of shots each tip was reactivated. 1.5cm tips were reactivated to 900 shots, whereas 1.0cm tips were reactivated to 450 shots.

None of the plastic tips were found to have any defects to be removed from the experiment as all of the used tips passed all testing results after each and every reactivation and testing procedure.

After all 20 Thermacool tips were used for 50,000 shots EACH, the tips were taken apart and their components were closely examined. The flexible circuits which comprise the membrane of the tips were sent to experts in the fields of RF and electronics circuitry. The integrity of the flexible circuit membranes were examined in detail and compared to the original new tips. The ability of the membranes to uniformly deliver RF energy and cryogen coolant was examined by the experts. The integrity of the contact leads and temperature sensors within the flexible circuit were also examined in detail and compared to the original tips.

Results

In total, approximately 1200 treatments were performed using the reactivated used Thermacool tips. A total of 50,000 shots were used on each of the 20 used Thermacool tips. The study was conducted over a period of 12 months.

Clinical results and the occurrence of side effects were compared to those from patients undergoing treatments with new Thermacool tips. The study found no increase in the rate of side effects between the reactivated tips and new tips. In specific, there was no significant difference in patient reports of increased pain, erythema, burns, infections or other complaints.

These results confirm that used Thermacool tips can be safely reactivated and used on multiple patients without increasing chances of infections as claimed by Thermage. Simple cleaning of the tip’s membrane with alcohol is sufficient in the control of infections with reusing Thermacool tips.

Occurrences of Infections:

New Tips: 0% Used Tips: 0%

No significant difference (p<0.001)

Occurrences of Burns:

New Tips: 0.06% Used Tips: 0.04%

No significant difference (p<0.01)

Occurrences of Other Side Effects:

New Tips: 4.35% Used Tips: 4.5%

No significant difference (p<0.01)

Patients with Noticeable Clinical Results:

New Tips: 85% Used Tips: 87%

No significant difference (p<0.01)

The study did not find any significant deterioration or compromise in the integrity of the tip’s membranes after 50,000 shots. This is based on the visual inspection of the tip’s membranes after each treatment, and on the final analysis of experts at the end of the experiment once the tips had been taken apart. All 20 tips used in the experiment did not fail even once throughout the full length of the experiment for the duration of 50,000 shots used on each tip. (p<0.01)

Analysis of the temperature sensors showed that all reactivated used tips continued to perform within the accepted range of the temperature sensors for the duration of the experiment. There was no significant difference in the ability of the used tips to detect temperature changes as compared to new Thermacool tips. Temperature readings from used tips ranged from 98% to 101% of readings from new tips. This coincides with the experts’ analysis that the temperature sensors which are used in the Thermacool tips have a very long life span and will last far more than the 50,000 shots used on each Thermacool tip. This was seen in all various temperatures which were measured.

Text Box: Comparison to readings from NEW tips.

The study also found no significant difference in the ability of the used tips to deliver cryogen coolant as compared to a new tip. Temperature changes measured at the tip’s membranes were no different in the used tips after 50,000 shots as compared to a new Thermacool tip. Temperature readings from used tips ranged from 97% to 102% of readings from new tips. This shows that used Thermacool tips can effectively deliver cryogen coolant to the tip’s membrane after repeated prolonged use.

Text Box: Comparison to readings from NEW tips.

img07.gif Conclusion

This study strongly confirms that Thermage Thermacool tips can be safely reactivated and reused for more than 50,000 shots. These findings apply to both the 1.0cm tips and 1.5cm Thermacool tips. The study found that there are no increased chances of infection or other side effects with reusing Thermacool tips, as long as simple measures are taken to clean the tips with alcohol and visually inspect the tip’s membrane.

The Thermacool tips can function safely for more than 50,000 shots and show the same clinical efficacy as a new tip. Used tips are just as effective as a new tip in delivering RF energy and cryogen coolant, proper and accurate sensing of skin temperature, and maintaining the integrity of the tip’s membrane. No deterioration of the tips’ membranes was found after 50,000 shots of use.

The findings in this study show that Thermage’s claims of decreased safety with reusing Thermacool tips are incorrect. It is clear that Thermage has limited the use of their Thermacool tips for monetary reasons only.

By attaching a newly programmed microchip to the used Thermacool tips, without any modifications or changes being made to the tip itself, doctors can safely and effectively reuse their Thermcool tips, thus lowering their overall treatment costs and expenses.

Reader Comments (23)

Dear sir:

I have great interest in the "Flexible circuit" to reactive the tips. Could you please tell me the way to order
this device ??

Thanks a lot
by Dr. Jye
12.8 | Unregistered CommenterJye
Can you tell me where I can get this reactivated chip for thermage?
interested MD & Dr. Jye,

I'm afraid that you'll have to search on the net. We don't actually use these although I'm aware of many doctors who do. Thermage generally dismisses these tips but some doctors are certainly using them.

According to my Thermage rep, Thermage has been totally unable to build a membrane that will last more than 900 hits consistantly. This is bogus of course.

I'll post more about this in the future.
If you are interested in the tip reactivation microchips, here is the e-mail: thermacool@hotmail.com
you will save lots of money, just ask them to send you all the info, it works good for me.
01.29 | Unregistered Commenterdoc55
I would like to have the prices for the refurbished tips and how to buy them
I AM LOOKING FOR CRYOGEN FOR THE THERMAGE MACHINE
This comment was offensive and has been removed and the IP that it origionated from has been blocked. Please be constructive in your comments. Vulgarity or name call will not be tolerated. (Jeff)
Dr./Mr. Ericksen,
I take offense to your passive aggressiveness. If you've got something to say about the topic that's concrete and derived from personal experience...shoot...you have an attentive audience. But seriously, your low balling should be reserved for the playground. This is not that kind of site.

If you think the above commentators are being cheap then why? What's your take? Make them listen. By commenting like you have above, you are ensuring that no one will give your future comments any credit or attention.
02.19 | Unregistered CommenterMidwest
Crio for thermage for cristina ferguson
i see this place but i not buy yet

http://appliedcosmeticalternatives.com/Thermage%20Cryogen.html
Hi,
How do i get the reactivated tips?i have lots of used tips already thanks

dr.calayan/philippines
reply pls
These tips have come from Japan and Brazil in the past. I think they're still available although I've not ordered any. I would guess that your best bet is to do a google search on Reactivated Thermage Tips.

Do you think this technique will work for the Aesthera PPx tips as well ?

06.15 | Unregistered CommenterDr Mike

I wonder what would cost more, a lawsuit from a patient that you burned using a used tip or spending an extra $100 on a new one?

i would like to have the price of thermacool machine and how to buy it

Also interrested in looking for reactivated tips. I have emailed the like that you provided above "thermacool@hotmail.com" and have had no reply in over a week. Just note, the patient whom I have done thermage on have been happy and I think that given the right patient selection they do relatively well.

thanks.
M. Hawkins

08.13 | Unregistered Commenterbonedoc

Doc55:
I contacted the thermacool@hotmail.com people, they sent me a sample one but I was not able to "activate" that tip. They told me maybe my machine was modified by Thermage so it could not use reactivated tips. I bought my machine in 2006. Any thoughts??? Thanks
pmdoc

09.19 | Unregistered Commenterpmdoc

I used two or three times the reactivated tips, now the Thermage distributor has cancelled my warranty on the equipment and refuse to sell me more tips because they say I broke the agreemnt I signed. They even mentioned me that they will pursue legal actions if I continue using the tips, they even contacted the Spanish medical asociation and I had to go for an interview.....certainly not worth the $100 less paid for all the loss I have now..

01.30 | Unregistered CommenterSpainDoc

the e-mail address doesn't work. Any other way we can get this? I have a question for thermage people: What if all your multimeters in your factory were set to be used for only ten readings or so. The tips would be just fine. BUT one circuit inside would not let you guys use the multimeter. How would you feel?

Maybe we should all do more studies like this, get rock solid evidence, and sue thermage for fleecing the patients and causing unprecedented deliberate price hike for the end- user.

06.29 | Unregistered Commenterskindocmd

I tried the thermacool@hotmail.com address but get a delivery failure message. Does anyone know of another source for the refurbished treatment tips?

03.14 | Unregistered CommenterDr. P

Hi guys, we are also looking for these tips but having a lot of difficulty finding them, could anyone point me in the right direction?

Cheers

Hi all,

We wish to know how to buy reactivated thermage tips. please contact me via alfredspirit@gmail.com

Thanks

08.25 | Unregistered CommenterAlfred

this is the result for over pricing your tips.

the operators will try to find cheaper or reactivated tips.
perhaps the result may not be as good or as safe as the brand new tip
eventually, someone gets hurt, or produces little or result.

Syneron's first consumable tip only had 100 pulses. They reinvented the tip to be 200 shots, now all the tips are at 400 shots. They also reduced the prices of their other consumable tips.

08.26 | Unregistered CommenterMandy

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

Join Medical Spa MD

captcha
MEDICAL SPA MD
Medical Spa MD

A community of dermatologists, plastic surgeons, laser clinics, & skin clinics world wide.

Medical Spa MD is a world-wide community of physicians and clinicians practicing cosmetic medicine. Please read our Terms of Service, Advertising Terms and Privacy Policy.

Copyright © 2011. All rights reserved.

LEGAL NOTICE & TERMS OF SERVICE